3
Min Read
Product Guides

Mulch, Bark, or Compost?

Mulch, bark dust, and compost all help your garden thrive—but they serve different purposes. Learn what sets them apart and how to choose the right one for your landscape.

Whether you're maintaining a backyard garden, reworking a flower bed, or just trying to keep weeds down in your front yard, you've probably come across mulch, bark dust, and compost. These materials are often used interchangeably, but they’re not the same—and using the right one in the right place can make a big difference in the health and appearance of your landscape.

Here's what you need to know.

What Is Mulch?

Mulch is a broad term for any material spread over the surface of the soil to retain moisture, suppress weeds, regulate temperature, and improve visual appeal. It can be organic (wood chips, straw, leaves) or inorganic (rubber, gravel).

Uses:

  • Suppresses weeds
  • Holds in soil moisture
  • Protects roots from extreme temperatures
  • Gives beds a finished, tidy look

Best for: Flower beds, around trees and shrubs, and pathways where you want a clean look and long-term ground cover.

What Is Bark Dust?

Bark dust is a specific type of organic mulch made from finely shredded or ground bark—usually from fir or hemlock trees. It’s valued for its smooth, uniform texture and deep color, making it popular for decorative landscaping.

Uses:

  • Same benefits as mulch: weed control, moisture retention, temperature moderation
  • Adds a rich, consistent look to beds and borders

Best for: High-visibility areas where appearance matters, like front yards, commercial properties, or decorative beds.

Note: Bark dust is slower to break down than other mulches, so it lasts longer but doesn’t enrich the soil much on its own.

What Is Compost?

Compost is decomposed organic matter—kitchen scraps, yard waste, leaves, and manure—that’s broken down into a rich, crumbly soil amendment. It’s packed with nutrients and teeming with beneficial microbes.

Uses:

  • Improves soil structure and fertility
  • Boosts microbial life in the soil
  • Helps retain water while improving drainage

Best for: Mixing into garden beds before planting, topdressing lawns or vegetable gardens, and rejuvenating depleted soil.

Important distinction: Compost is not mulch. While you can use it as a top layer, it breaks down quickly and can encourage weed growth if not covered.

Quick Comparison Table

Choosing the Right One

  • Want healthy soil? Start with compost.
  • Need a neat, polished look? Go with bark dust.
  • Trying to control weeds and conserve moisture? Mulch (or bark dust as a type of mulch) is your friend.
  • Looking for long-term cover? Bark dust holds up better than lighter mulches.

Each of these materials plays a different role in a thriving landscape. Think of compost as food for your soil, mulch as its blanket, and bark dust as the stylish coat you put on top. Use them wisely, and your plants—and your property—will thank you.